Skip to main content

BDP Attorneys – A Leading Law Firm in Tyger Valley

Section 71 of the Companies Act, 2008 (the “Companies Act”) sets out the framework for the removal of directors and distinguishes clearly between removal by fellow directors and removal by shareholders.

Where directors seek to remove a fellow director, section 71(4) of the Companies Act requires the board to provide written reasons for the proposed removal to the affected director before the meeting at which the resolution is to be considered. By contrast, section 71(2), which governs removal by shareholders, imposes no such obligation to furnish reasons.

Despite this distinction, the Western Cape High Court in the Timcke decision held that, in line with the principles of natural justice, a director facing removal by shareholders must be provided with reasons prior to the shareholders’ meeting called to vote on the resolution to remove the director. The court held that an obligation on shareholders to provide reasons to the affected director ought to be read into section 71(2).

The position regarding the requirements applicable to the removal of directors by shareholders has now been clarified in the recent judgment of Weir v Wiehahn Formwork Solutions (Pty) Ltd and Others. In considering the requirements under section 71(2), relating to the removal of directors by shareholders, the Western Cape High Court held that the Timcke decision was clearly wrong. The court emphasized that shareholders, unlike directors, do not owe fiduciary duties to the company and are entitled to act in their own interests – including the removal of directors they appointed.

This judgment has now resolved the legal uncertainty surrounding the requirements for shareholderdriven director removals under section 71. The only procedural requirements shareholders must meet under sections 71(1) and (2) are:

  1. Notice: Providing advance notice to the affected director of the shareholders’ meeting and the proposed resolution for removal; and
  2. Opportunity to Respond: Allowing the director a reasonable opportunity to make a presentation at the meeting before the resolution is voted upon.

Anton Schelhase

Director – Corporate and
Commercial

Email: anton.schelhase@bdplaw.co.za

Cell: (+27)82 468 1824

Andrea Keller

Director – Corporate and
Commercial

Email: andrea.keller@bdplaw.co.za

Cell: (+27)82 821 5054

Caleb Jones

Director – Corporate and
Commercial

Email: caleb.jones@bdplaw.co.za

Cell: (+27)69 4488 944

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to browse, you agree to our use of cookies
X